Silver And Black Pride: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Around SBN: Baby Boilers no more: Michigan State-Purdue Preview

Oakland Raiders News: Deconstructing The 2009 NFL Draft

 

Wow, it feels like forever since I’ve had two unaccounted for hours to sit here on my chaise lounge and muse about my favorite football team. So, finally, this morning I am sitting in the Bay Window, watching Beauty and the Geek 2008 re-runs, and breaking down the last five seasons of drafts in looking for sure things in the First Round by position. God I love Blogging!!!

Last season I was all about us drafting a wide receiver in the 2nd Round, until we traded for DeAngelo “Who”. Oddly enough, had we NOT made that trade, my pick Desean Jackson would have been there for the taking and that would have made me perfect in calling the first two rounds in consecutive years. That doesn’t mean that the Raiders would have picked Jackson, it just means that HAD they not, I could have sent a raspberry to Alameda and lobbied for a job in scouting.

 This year’s draft is going to be more difficult because there will be tempting players available at #7, like Michael Crabtree and Orapko, while there will should be solid players that fill needs like Eugene Monroe available.

 So, for today’s experiment, I have decided to compile lists of players drafted in the Top 10 by position and rank them into 3 categories, Stud, Middle of the Road, Bust.

 

Without further ado, here is the list:

 

Studs

 QB: Matt Ryan, Eli Manning, Philip Rivers

 OL: Jake Long (T),  Joe Thomas (T), Levi Brown (T), D’Brickashaw Ferguson

 RB: Darren McFadden, Adrian Peterson, Reggie Bush, Ronnie Brown

 WR: Calvin Johnson (WR), Braylon Edwards, Roy Williams, Larry Fitzgerald, Kellen Winslow (TE)

 DL: Sedrick Ellis (DT), Mario Williams (DE)

 LB: Keith Rivers (WLB), Jerod Mayo, AJ Hawk, Ernie Sims

 DB: LaRon Landry (SS), Carlos Rogers (CB), Antrel Rolle (CB), Sean Taylor (RIP), DeAngelo Hall (CB), Dunta Robinson (CB)

 

Jury’s Still Out

 QB: JaMarcus Russell, Matt Leinert

 OL: Robert Gallery (Probably a Stud Though)

 RB: Cadillac Williams

 WR:

 DL: Chris Long (DE), Glen Dorsey (DT), Derrick Harvey (DE), Gaines Adams (DE)

 LB:

 CB: Donte Whitner (SS),

 

Bust

 QB: Vince Young, Alex Smith

 OL:

 RB: Cedrick Benson

 WR: Ted Ginn Jr., Vernon “Click Clack” Davis, Troy Williamson, Mike Williams, Reggie Williams

 DL: Vernon Gholston (DE), Amobi Okoye (DE), Jamaal Anderson (DE)

 LB:

 DB: Michael Huff (SS), Pacman Jones (CB)

 

With the Raiders needs being a run stopping MLB, Shut down corner, Sure tackling and good coverage FS, O-Line and Wide Receiver, this data may prove useful.

 

Five out of 10 pass catchers have been busts. The one thing the each of the studs have in common is that they are quick, have great hands and are large targets that can elevate. Does Michael Crabtree fill that description? The answer is YES!!!

Crabtree is Six foot Three, 214 pounds, with great hands and he can elevate. If he is there, at this point, he is my pick.

I know that some of you in the Nation are saying, WHAT? You think that we need to take an Offensive lineman with that first round pick. My argument is that at #7, there will not be a player the caliber any of the studs available and the 2nd round has produced some pretty capable linemen, whereas ther will not be a receiver left in Crabtree's class.

 

Another thing that I noticed is that the linebackers who were rated high coming out of College have been studs so far. Rivers, Mayo, Willis, Hawk and Sims would definitely help shore up the run D.

Rey Maualuga may just be what this team needs on defense and if Crabtree is off the board I could see him becoming a Raider. He is just THAT good.

 

What also stands out here is that it may not be a bad idea to draft a shutdown corner to replace Nnamdi IF Nnamdi will not commit long term. If the raiders can pull off a Jared Allen like trade for him, then the team can get VERY healthy in this year's draft.

Malcolm  Jenkins would be a great addition, even if we keep Nnamdi this year, but I think that it would be a waste of a pick if we were NOT going to move Nnamdi.

 

What stands out to you on this list? Who would you move around? Would you trade Nnamdi and draft Jenkins?

 

he more I look at the draft lists, I am thinking that we should trade down to #11!!!

 Check out the list of players taken at #11 over the past 5 years.: Leodis McKelvin, Patrick Willis, DeMarcus Ware, Ben Roethlisburger, Jay Cutler!!!!

0 recs  |  Comment 16 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Seattle will most definitely get Crabtree

injury heavy receiving corps with no real studs. Might also take RB or OL, but Crabtree will be their pick. After that WR really drops off except for Harvin, but I think Harvin could very well be available in the second if we haven’t taken a WR yet and would still like to.

I still would like us to get any of the three amongst Smith, Oher, or Monroe. Monroe is easily this year’s Clady and both Smith and Oher are similar to Jake Long, but better. Monroe is still my fave because of success in a ZBS and is a balanced run and pass blocker.

My real pick though is Maualuga. You will never see this kind of talent come into the draft for a long time. I see absolutely no down-side to drafting Ray. If he’s taken, I’d also take a serious look at Laurinitas (or however that’s spelled) Not as good in coverage as Maualuga, but he’s got more bulk, more size, and more strength.

As for CB, I don’t see that as too much of a need. Neither is FS. I think those are our two big concerns for FA. WE have bigger concerns than these two positions this year with needs of added O-Line and D-Line depth, MLB, OLB depth, and WR depth.

That’s my opinion of the draft.

Silver and Black Pride: Where Bacon hating happens
Fear the Fin: Where Sharks cakes happen
Athletics Nation: Where Billy Bean happens
Pounding the Rock: Where otstanding happens
Rakes of Mallow: Where Brady Quinn happens
S&B Nation: Where lazy people have nothing better to do happens

by KA1Z3R on Jan 31, 2009 1:07 PM PST reply actions   0 recs

I wish the Raiders could trade down

but that doesn’t happen much anymore. Philly has two 1st round picks, would be great if they wanted Crabtree enough to give us their two for our one. Knowing Al and how he operates I have to believe he will go for Crabtree if available, Al loves offense and doesn’t usually expend 1st picks on defensive players, a mistake as far as I am concerned. He used to draft OL in the first round, Lawrence, Shell, Upshaw, Stinchcomb, and several others I have probably forgotten. Of course, Gallery. You are the first person who suggested Ferguson is a stud, they have been somewhat unhappy with him in NY from what I have read.
I agree with you about not picking on OL in this draft, that can be filled in the later rounds, there are teams in this league with good lines with players drafted from the 5th on, with some undrafted guys. It will never happen but sure wish the Raiders would go defense in this draft, specifically LB. I guess I hold out hope that Cable can convince Nnamdi that the Raiders are coming back and so should he. Al will pay him the money, Al has never been cheap with players. If he won’t sign then trade him by all means. He has got to bring a 1st and 3rd round pick, I can live with that. NFL players are expendable, nobody other than a QB is that important. I guess I am alone in thinking that WR is not crucial to the success of this team. Two guys with promise are coming off injuries, Walker was once a very good player, and Higgins and
Schilens look like keepers. I keep reading that the Raiders had no receivers with very many catches and point to lack of receivers. I point to lack of QB play early in the season, and the fact that all the receivers other than Higgins were hurt most of the season. Of course, the Raiders didn’t have any receivers with many catches. Add that to the fact that Russell frankly didn’t look very good in about 8 games last year and it is not surprising. Of course all this is speculation until after the free agency signings. If Al is able to sign a big time linebacker or pass rusher then whatever is done in the draft is fine with me. This is a pretty exciting time of the year with signings, draft, cuts etc.
The virtue of keeping Cable is that he knows this team, knows their weaknesses and has shown a willingness to let guys go who don’t produce. Give Huff one more year, maybe he will finally show why he was drafted in the first round, maybe not.

by Laoren on Jan 31, 2009 1:15 PM PST reply actions   0 recs

Al goes defense late in the first:

Nnamdi, Buchanon, Fabian Washington and Michael Huff (7th pick) have been drafted in recent years.

I almost made D’Brick a 2nd tier player, but he has shown moments of Supreme Brilliance.

We need a REAL #1 receiver. Crabtree can be that guy. Then again, I want to see what Shields has,

But when they start scheming us the way these guys did, and we weren't particularly ready for it, anything can happen."

by saint on Jan 31, 2009 1:26 PM PST up reply actions   0 recs

Isn't the problem with drafting a WR

the fact we are stuck with Walker? How many WR’s does a team carry? I think only 5 and with Schilens, Walker, Carter, Shields and Higgins the Raiders already have 5. I know that Curry is gone and we don’t have to sign Carter, and perhaps Higgins is a special teams guy and we don’t need to count him on the WR ledger. I just don’t see the WR position as a great need.

by Laoren on Feb 1, 2009 9:27 AM PST up reply actions   0 recs

AJ Hawk and Ernie Sims are not studs.

They’re solid players, although with Hawk even that is questionable.

Nice article, but my question is what’s the point of having a stud receiver if you can’t even get him the ball? Russell needs time to pass, the line was horrific, so a lineman should be taken. Crabtree has question marks anyway (speed?), he’s no Calvin Johnson. And I wouldn’t call Braylon Edwards or Roy Williams studs either. Williams hasn’t been good in 2 years and Edwards just led the league in drops. He’s coming off a hugely disappointing season. I would bet both teams regret those picks (well except for the fact the Lions stole a first round pick from the Cowboys for Roy Williams).

This is the perfect year to take a great O-lineman as there are a few available so one will be there at the #7 pick. No reason to take a corner just in case Nhamdi leaves when there is such a perfect fit to fill a huge need on the O-line.

by Brendan Scolari on Jan 31, 2009 7:08 PM PST reply actions   0 recs

nice post

still think we should go oline in the first round though. hehe

Don't confuse me with the facts, my mind is made up!!

by naq92 on Jan 31, 2009 7:46 PM PST reply actions   0 recs

You guys are dreamers

Firts off Crabtree will NOT be there so stop thinking about him. Trading down would be great, but with salary cap issues around the league and a deep draft, I dont see us getting anything done in that regard. That being said Eugene Monroe should be the pick at #1. As for #2 I see some mock drafts have us getting The WR from Maryland Heyward-Bey. I didnt know who he was so I went to the net for some highlights and this kid is the real deal,,, But alas I doubt he will slip to us, if he does though I think it would be a great pick. I also see a chance in the second to get the DT from USC Fili Moala (sp?) or Lauranitis the LB from Ohio state if there, I think he could fill the MLB postion better than Mr. Morrison, who Iove but he is too small for the MLB position,, we could move him outside and have 3 special LB’s.

by raiderfan60 on Feb 1, 2009 6:12 AM PST reply actions   0 recs

Laurinitas won't be there in the second

Some draft experts have him being better than Maualuga, others not. but Laurinitas is too good of a MLB to drop to the second.

As for Hayward-Bey, this guy is insanely good. He could easily round out our receiving corps, but I wouldn’t hold my breath on him. Several mock drats have him going in the late 1st. or the second round before the Raiders pick.

Silver and Black Pride: Where Bacon hating happens
Fear the Fin: Where Sharks cakes happen
Athletics Nation: Where Billy Bean happens
Pounding the Rock: Where otstanding happens
Rakes of Mallow: Where Brady Quinn happens
S&B Nation: Where lazy people have nothing better to do happens

by KA1Z3R on Feb 1, 2009 6:23 AM PST up reply actions   0 recs

I finally seen this guy

Love his no fear mentality. This attribute does so much for a receiver.

Wack To Mack With The General and The Back. (J-Mac and D-Mac)

by Rayder K on Feb 1, 2009 10:01 AM PST up reply actions   0 recs

I watched plenty of Maryland this year

Teams knew he was their only real receiving threat, they doubled him, and he still came out projected as one of the top WR in the draft.

Silver and Black Pride: Where Bacon hating happens
Fear the Fin: Where Sharks cakes happen
Athletics Nation: Where Billy Bean happens
Pounding the Rock: Where otstanding happens
Rakes of Mallow: Where Brady Quinn happens
S&B Nation: Where lazy people have nothing better to do happens

by KA1Z3R on Feb 1, 2009 1:32 PM PST up reply actions   0 recs

Mock Draft

Looking over last year’s 3 closest losses, which if converted to wins gets us to a .500 season and should be our next goal. Playoffs, AFC champs and Super Bowl Champs are bigger steps. If we look at why we likely lost to Buffalo, San Diego and Miami we see that late in the game we did not make a few first downs, control some clock and score at least a few points. I believe we look at our needs to convert those losses to wins. Obviously, we won’t have the same exact opportunites next year as this year. What we need is some offensive help. I believe in the first 10 picks you pick guys that touch the ball. If Stafford is there at #7 you pick him. But he won’t be. Ditto for Crabtree. The sleeper at #7 is N.Moreno. This kid has Bo Jackson size and speed. We can have a big back and a speed back. Moreno could be a small slot or a motion rb / receiver. Pick the best OL in the 2nd round

by bugyoucrazy on Feb 1, 2009 1:55 PM PST reply actions   0 recs

I'm not sure you put Run DMC as a stud just yet.

I don’t think we saw him enough to put him in that category. I’d say Jury is still out on him. Also, I’d switch Gallery with Huff. Gallery was what, a number 2 pick, and is arguably our best O-linemen, which is not that great to begin with. As for Huff, I think he’s been pretty solid so far.

"Monta is the MAN." -Bob Fitzgerald

by WarriorForLife on Feb 1, 2009 7:42 PM PST reply actions   0 recs

As in Michael Huff?

As in the guy that got benched because he was underperforming? The same guy that dropped an interception? The same man that got burnt a lot and couldn’t tackle? Is that the Michael Huff you’re saying is solid?

Win, Lose, or Tie, Raiders til I die!

by mikesd1981 on Feb 2, 2009 4:43 AM PST up reply actions   0 recs

you forgot that he tackles like Stu

as in he doesn’t tackle

Silver and Black Pride: Where Bacon hating happens
Fear the Fin: Where Sharks cakes happen
Athletics Nation: Where Billy Bean happens
Pounding the Rock: Where otstanding happens
Rakes of Mallow: Where Brady Quinn happens
S&B Nation: Where lazy people have nothing better to do happens

by KA1Z3R on Feb 2, 2009 1:57 PM PST up reply actions   0 recs

The same man that got burnt a lot and couldn’t tackle?

Win, Lose, or Tie, Raiders til I die!

by mikesd1981 on Feb 2, 2009 4:13 PM PST up reply actions   0 recs

Crabtree gone.....

i too think Crabtree will be gone before #7. But if he drops, we should take him. I think we had the chance to get fitzgerald instead of gallery. If crabtree is gone, we should go o-line. i just hope our talent scouts pick a good ol. It seems that todays successful teams are those with good def and good o-line (pitt ol got off to a slow start this year). So if we dont get crabtree and we pass on ol, I too like Rey (the next seau), dl, or another lb.

by gl12ox05 on Feb 2, 2009 10:43 AM PST reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation Blog about the Oakland Raiders.
Start posting about the Raiders »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Comcast NFL RedZone Moments from SB Nation

Music City Miracles
Tennessee Titans Red Zone Report
Bleeding Green Nation
Comcast NFL Red Zone stat of the week - Something doesn't have to give
Niners Nation
49ers Red Zone numbers: How effective are they?

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Habemus_papum_small
Caveat Raiders: Deep South Players Fail in Oakland
Raiders_logo_small
SABP 2010 NFL Mock Draft Open Thread
Small
Owners have the edge over players this Free Agency season
Chrishanburgerlegends_small
Canton's Voters Once Again Show They Know Nothing
Rj_small
NFL 2010 Draft//QB Situation
Raymond_small
Warren Sapp Questioned by Police:
Raiders_logo_small
Super Bowl XLIV Odds and Ends
Dsc03827_small
I could get behind an evil talent like Vick
Small
Oakland Raiders Positional Breakdown and Draft Possibilities: The Offense
Dsc02508_1__small
Deion Sanders. Pimp suit punk.

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

Big Blue View
Eli talks Peyton, Super Bowl
Niners Nation
100 in 100: Tony Pike (29 of 100)
The Falcoholic
Dave's Rad New Logo Idea

SPONSORS


Editors

Raiders_logo_small TheRaiderWay

Jamarcus_small LiveAdam

Authors

Sunkist_small KA1Z3R

Edge_small Rated-R Superstar

Habemus_papum_small Sons-of-Blanda