Silver and Black Pride's Sunday Community Poll: The Hot Seat
Thirty-two days and counting until the start of training camp for our Oakland Raiders and it can't get here quick enough. I don't know about all of you, but enough of this offseason lull and boredom, let's get ready for some football!
In this lull period before the draft choice signings and before camp starts, it is pretty difficult to find Raider related things to write about. However, I was thinking that when camp does start, that besides the multiple areas where there will be competition, there are a select few players that either have something to prove or will be on the Hot Seat a soon as camp commences. The Hot Seat means that the player is in danger of either being released, demoted or a downgrade in expectations.
Players worth mentioning because of the their "reach" status where they were drafted, but will not be included in this poll, are Heyward-Bey and Mike Mitchell because they like all of the 2009 rookies get at least a one year grace period before they get to the "Hot Seat".
The players that are on the Hot Seat coming into the 2009 camp are:
From the offense:
- JaMarcus Russell - At 23 years old, being drafted as a junior and really with only one full season under his belt, if Russell was drafted with the 25th pick in the first round, he would not be on the Hot Seat. But when you are the first player taken in the draft, you are on the Hot Seat from the moment you sign the contract. With Russell being pushed by Cable and Garcia, having experienced position coaches tutoring him and now having a supporting cast to work with, 2009 is the year that Russell must validate his status as being selected No.1 and prove he is the face of the franchise at least on offense.
- Arman Shields - Drafted in the 4th round last year, Shields never saw the field in 2008 due to injuries. With the Raiders bringing in an influx of new blood at the wide receiver position to go along with Schilens and JLH, Shields will have to be a camp stand-out in order to make the cut this year, as the Raiders will likely only keep five WR's on their roster.
- Javon Walker - The time is now for the former Pro-Bowler, even though Walker restructured his contract this year and "appears" to be healthy and ready for camp, the patience of the Raider organization this year with Walker will be thin. Walker is the only true veteran with experience at the WR position and if he can contribute like he should be capable of, then he will be a real asset to the team not just for production, but for the mentoring of the youngsters.
From the defense:
- John Bowie - Drafted in 2007, Bowie is infamously known as the player that the Raiders got for Randy Moss. Due to injuries, Bowie has not seen much of the field either for the Raiders and he will come into camp with long odds to make the cut if he doesn't show that he is worthy of making the final 53. He first must prove that he can stay healthy and then that he can suitably play his position, something so far from the OTA's, he has not excelled at.
- Michael Huff - Drafted in 2006 with the 7th pick, Huff has yet to show any of the abilities that he displayed in Texas. In fact, Huff has been a liability to the defense with his poor angles and apparent fear of tackling, which led ultimately to his benching last season. Granted, Huff has been moved around between strong and free safety, quite possibly been misused and not taught the proper techniques by the Rob Ryan regime, but Huff so far has not shown the Raiders anything yet to expunge the "bust" label that he has acquired. With Tyvon Branch and Mitchell in the house as well as the Raiders other offseason acquisitions, Huff will have to come into camp showing that he has progressed and acquired new good habits to replace his poor habits.
- Terdell Sands - For a man that is 6-7, 335 pounds, Sands sure does disappear a lot on the field. Sands got the big contract and was supposed to be the big plug in the middle, tying up lineman, closing gaps and allowing the linebackers to make plays. Instead we get a guy who is out of shape, easily gassed and is usually one step late to the play. Maybe there is a Rob Ryan factor here as well, maybe now that Greg Ellis is here along with the new coaching staff, Sands will "get it", if not, what he will get are his walking papers.
So Raider Nation, training camp is thankfully soon upon us, which player do you think has the most to prove to get off the Hot Seat?
0 recs |
11 comments
|
Comments
Russell is not the hot seat
since all QB’s never get off it. Russell has had one year of playing, and measured up quite well with other one year players from the past. Everybody will talk about Ryan and Flacco but that is comparing apples and oranges. Until the last game the Raiders had no running attack and for most of the year their defense was pitiful, not to mention never did have a quality receiver the entire season. Throw in the Kiffin/Davis fiasco, the changes of coaches etc. Russell did just fine. Of course he is on the hot seat, every QB is.
In my mind Huff is the most obvious choice, a high pick, and going into the 4th year he has been a disappointment. No doubt he will be cut soon.
by Laoren on Jun 28, 2009 10:25 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
You know ESPN
and all the other Football networks will be all over Jamarcus’ balls if he doesn’t do well and frankly he has absolutely no excuse inexperience is not a excuse and especially if we can have our Defense step up and make those third down stops, Darren McFadden healthy is a what a QB dreams of and we got that so there are no excuses and I put my expectations high for Jamarcus this year with 28 TD passes.
Amazing, Jamarcus Russell hands off to McFadden who pitches it back to Russell who finds Darrius Heyward Bey in the Middle of the Field wide open 30, 20,10,5 Touchdown Raiders! Amazing. This telecast is Brought to you by Cable.
by nishal26 on Jun 28, 2009 10:54 AM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
The most difficult position on the football field
is the QB position. I also have high expectations but it is not an island either. A QB must have blocking, must have time, and must have receivers who can catch the ball and do something with it. It helps of course if the runners make yards, control the ball and the game does not hinge upon the QB making every throw. I think Russell has the right stuff, now he must show it along with the other parts the team has added, time will tell like it always does.
by Laoren on Jun 28, 2009 2:42 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
+1
i totally agree w/ what you said about Russell. I voted Walker though. I feel he has more to prove after everything that went down last year from the huge contract, to the Vegas incidient, to the IR. I feel he has more to prove than Huff. but its close.. :)
Don't confuse me with the facts, my mind is made up!!
by naq92 on Jun 28, 2009 3:23 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
It has to be Russell because he’s the quarterback and that has to prove himself. Yes, it doesn’t all have to click this year. Yes, it’s not really fair to him, but that’s the reality of the situation. He’s the quarterback and he has to mature and prove by his actions that he is ready to do this and to lead this team.
The Ultimate Opportunist
by Rated-R Superstar on Jun 28, 2009 2:50 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Huff
I’m torn between Huff and Walker; also Sands a bit. However, I don’t think Sands too much cause there have been no real improvements through FA or the Draft to warrant any talk about the DT’s this year.
I didn’t choose Walker cause he really is the only veteran. I for some reason also feel that he will be back to form this year; I’m sure he is finally all settled mentally. He probably only restructured his deal with an agreement that he wouldn’t get cut this year. I think he’s staying and will perform.
Huff however must be worried. He has been terrible all the years he has been here and he was benched last year. We also drafted Mitchell in the second and I believe we brought a couple guys in from FA. I think if he doesn’t do well in training camp then he is getting cut.
Also, how come you don’t have CABLE on the hot seat? Give Al’s recent history with coaches I would think Cable is probably on the hottest seat this year.
Just HIT somebody.
by SBcitizen on Jun 28, 2009 4:00 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
i agree w/ what you said about Huff
but dude, theres no way ANYONE gave walker an agreement to not be cut. There’s too many reasons to cut him.
Don't confuse me with the facts, my mind is made up!!
by naq92 on Jun 30, 2009 12:41 AM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
I voted for Terdell Sands
I think that the run defense has some much to do with the success of this team because its obvious that in this league u win or lose on third down and the key to third down is having positive plays on first and second and that usually means running the ball succesfully.
so when u can run the ball on 1st and 2nd down then u get third and short ur chances of success dramatically improve because of the length of time ur QB takes to drop back on third down an obvious passing down while blitzers and ends are coming to tee off on him He’s in a three step drop
if we cant stop the run were alwasy gonna be defending third and short leaving our defense constantly guessing and never given the oppurtunity to succeed i dont know what the percentages are but i would guess most turnovers come on third down and long when a QB tries to force something and thats where are run defense controls are destiny we need to make teams one dimnesial on third down and then unleash on them so please MR sands mr warren and mr kelly stay in great shape and come to camp hungry to kill RB’s in ur gaps before gaining yardage
"The only yardstick for success our society has is being a champion. No one remembers anything else."
by BRIANMULHALL on Jun 28, 2009 4:09 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
JR
Most definitely JR. I cannot understand some of the fans handling him with kid’s gloves and making excuses for him. As an NFL top selection has a lot to live up to in order to avoid the bust label, and holding out his rookie year did not impress too many as a showing of dedication to be a real NFL QB, $ and bling aside. But then, this is a typical Davis type QB.
As for Huff, I do not see him as being on the hot seat, mainly because he is already a bust and everyone knows it. More likely it would be considered a miracle if he actually turned into a decent player. I don’t think many are expecting that though.
by lurker88 on Jun 28, 2009 7:43 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
raiders quterbacks
will jeff garcia be the next jim plunkett for the raiders
by winky316 on Jul 5, 2009 9:18 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs

by 
















