New NFL Football Rules: How Long Before Two Hand Touch?
It's been a long time my fine S&BP brethren, the lockout and other things have kept me from writing on here and I apologize. But I've been holding this in for a long time and I have to let off some steam. I respect Roger Goodell for cleaning up the league and heavily reducing the illegal conduct of the players.
Let's face facts here, the NFL is becoming incredibly soft. As I type this, Mike Golic is going off on how the NFL's becoming so soft. His view point and my own are very similar. I hate these long intros, so let's just delve right in to then nitty gritty after the jump.
A couple days ago, I was watching my Raiders Super Bowl DVD. I loved watching the year in review movie for each Super Bowl season. And in watching that DVD, I found two things.
- Reggie Kinlaw is a horribly underrated Raiders player.
- The league is boringly soft now.
The league used to be full of the biggest, baddest, and toughest guys in the world. They were gargantuan monsters who wanted to beat the snot out of the guy across from them. These players were what built the stereotypical football player that the kids see in their goofy cartoons. Larger than life, growling and snarling with evil in their eyes, and just itching to crush someone.
I'd hate to see what football episodes of cartoons would be like if they were based on today's NFL. Instead of the cartoon character who's over his head playing football getting flattened by two guys. He'd just get pulled down to the ground. The football characters looking much smaller, with less hatred, less nastiness, less appealing.
Okay, so maybe that analogy wasn't crystal clear. So here's a stark reality for everyone. You ready?
My high school's football team plays tougher and harder football than the NFL players. Now you'll say that's horribly wrong. That only the best players and best hitters go to the NFL. No duh. Of course Ray Lewis, or even guys as low as Ricky Brown will hit harder than a high school kid.
I'm talking for their age and their level of play comparatively, my high school team is playing harder and tougher football.
NFL Rule: Can't put all your weight on a QB.
Someone should have told that to our team's defense. Can't tell you how many times we'd have two or three guys jump right on top of the QB trying to crush him.
NFL Rule: Can't lead with your helmet to tackle.
Someone should have told our arch rival that. We always beat the crap out of them, but not without getting speared by a helmet into the ribs countless times.
NFL Rule: No head to head collisions.
Trust me on this one. In a single-A high school stadium, you'll hear so many helmets cracking together you'd think there was a guy sitting beside you popping his own popcorn.
NFL Rule: No launching (leaving your feet) into a tackle.
I won't even go into how stupid I think this rule is, I'm just glad that's not in the high school rule book or else no team would be able to field enough players due to suspensions from repeated violations of this rule.
So why in the world is this? The NFL is full of investments and highly paid players and teams don't want to blow all their money on a concussion case? That's risk of playing the owner's game. High school is full of young men and women, kids compared to NFL players. Their bodies not as strong, not as battle-tested, not as developed.
And when those young men take the field, they're at more risk of injury, and their lives hardly begun. An NFL player is probably already set for life. Yet these kids are out there playing harder and more physical for their level of football. Why? Because somewhere along the way it seems that the NFL forgot what the F stands for. What football stands for.
Football is one of the truest sports metaphors for life. Any Given Sunday is only challenged by Rocky in my mind as the best sports movie that is actually about life. The only reason Rocky doesn't win it for me is because Al Pacino gives one hell of a great speech.
Football isn't just a game for these guys, it's life. But yet football in the NFL got misconstrued. A league that favors QB's to the point it's sickening and will do whatever it can to the defense to get Arena League scoring numbers without the gimmicks. All the while caring more about their precious investments and avoiding lawsuits about injured retired players, than the spirit and heart of the game.
Any Given Sunday was made around 2000, just 11 years ago. The football of that era that they're portraying, just 11 years ago, was far more physical and soulful than what we have now. It's sad honestly. The tackles on TV are nothing compared to what it used to be. Even the interactions between the WR and DB's in coverage are nothing more than a game of patty cake. What happened to real in-your-face press coverage?
Now the only rule I honestly am in agreement with towards safety is helmet-to-helmet collisions. It's unnecessary, incredibly dangerous, and shouldn't be in any level of football. I mean you never want people to go from a star 28-year old having the time of his life, to 50 year old with major brain damage and dementia.
However, the league shouldn't take away from the physical nature that makes football great to keep that from happening. The only safety measure that should be needed, is when that player signs his contract. When he decides to play pro, or play college, play high school, or even play pee-wee.
The decision on whether or not to play football and accept the risks that come with the raw physical battle that is football is made when you take that first look at the label on the back of your helmet.
WARNING: THIS HELMET DOES NOT GUARANTEE PROTECTION AGAINST CONCUSSIONS, HEAD TRAUMAS, PARALYSIS, OR DEATH.
Players know the risks. They always have. From the days of leather helmets, to the one bar, to the ugly revolution facemasks and futuristic helmets. From Jim Brown, to Johnny Unitas, to Joe Namath, to Roger Staubach, to Jack Lambert, to Howie Long, to Warren Moon, to Ray Lewis, to Adrian Peterson, to Cam Newton; they know the risks.
But they still want to play football. They've come this far watching the big mean physical games of the past, to playing the more casual blue collar high school game, to reaching college and having to reel back and playing soft and having to make a living doing so in the pros? Something just isn't adding up.
Just how long will it be before two hand touch becomes the norm? At this rate it'll be that way for QB's in only about 5 or 10 years. You already can't get up to hit a QB if you've been knocked down (the Brady rule), or put all your weight on them, or hit them below the waist. Gene Upshaw and Jack Tatum must be rolling in their graves.
I hope the day never comes. It may seem ridiculous and impossible to all of you out there. But let me ask this, did you think back in 1980 that things would be how they are now? Even as early as 2000 would you have thought that? Maybe my future son will be on here asking future S&BP members if they thought the now two-hand touch football league would have come to this back in 2010 or 2011. I sure hope not.
10 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Great post!
I hope the Raiders continue to play “old school football.” When you watch some of the old Raiders shows they’re talking about coaches telling Millen not to worry about getting a flag because “they’ll take care of it”. Villapiano said he rarely saw his fines, assuming Al Davis took care of it.
I know fines are a lot more pricier now, but Davis can’t take the money with him/
I'd wager that we don't have to worry about it over here.
Between McClain suplexing some poor Ram in the infield dirt and then playing up the crowd afterward and Seymour popping Roethlisberger in the face, I don’t think the Raiders will ever end up as sissified as Goodell wants. If nothing else, Davis will do anything he can to spite the league, even if it means taking penalties and paying fines.
by Jason Scarbrough on Jul 20, 2011 4:42 PM PDT up reply actions
Ive been screaming about this for years.
The NFL is getting softer and some of these new rules are just ridiculous.
Let them play, Goodell you pansy. If any new rule should be implemented, it should be that the commish of the NFL has to have played the game before.
Stop adding bullshit rules that are babying down the sport we love. I feel like the NFL is just one step away from joining the NBA.
The NBA thrives on tv ratings from the drama involved by Lebron James and his drama. I feel the NFL is getting there :(.
BRING BACK THE HARD HITS, LAYING THE WOOD ON A WR COMING UP THE MIDDLE IS HOW THE DEFENSE STOPS YOU.
Ka1z3r, you are on point. They need to stop making the defense useless. I enjoy watching the big hits from our defense. That hard nosed mentality that it takes to be a great defense. If you cant intimidate them with the big hits, it takes away from the defense. Think im crazy, go back and look at the numbers for the QB’s in the league over the last 10 yrs. As a matter of fact, its become so easy to score that they brought a primarily college formation in the Spread to the NFL.
I enjoy a 7-3 hard fought game as much as I enjoy a 55-51 thriller.
Sacramento Kings, Oakland Raiders. Best teams everrrrrrr
+ $10,000 Mil Because That's All It's About Now!!!...."OldSchool" So Some May Not Like My Response...
Starting to look like Pro Wrestling “BS”!!!…"QB"s n "K"s n "WR"s throwing themselves on the turf looking for that yellow rag…Hell last season when Rich took a small hand shove at “Dumb Ben” it was his theatrics that got the ejection…Laying there on the turf like he was hurt when he walked up and provoked it…Than laughing on the side lines…TV "Mediot"s show that damn crap and get idiots all wrapped up the after play confrontation instead of the game itself…
Don’t think our sport can’t become “Sissified”…I used to ride Rodeo back in the 70’s to early 80’s….Now they have helmets and body pads of every kind…Just freakin SICK!!!…Don’t even look like cowboys anymore and I can’t watch that pansy ass shit…We rode in that arena basically the same way we rode when breaking a green string…It’s a show of what it took to be a real cowboy…Than along came OSHA and safety laws pimped by the woman folk….
Same reason why you can’t see Olympic Boxing anymore during prime time….It’s all ribbon dancing and girls gymnastics…Well I do enjoy looking at their little asses but that’s not the point of my sports…It’s to be real!!!….Like Life is real!!!….
Than now the damn Players demand no more “2-a-Days” in Camp….Are you freakin kidding me…What ever happened to being men and training damn hard…Back in “HS” we called the 1st week of our Camp “Weenie Week” because the pussies were cut out before we ever got into the damn play book….So it’s not just the Owners and stupid “GoodWill” that are pimping this damn crap…Some crying retired Players along with the NFLPA trying to prolong the playing time and $$$$ of their Rank-n-File…
Now I have a right to speak…I’m a retired steel worker due to injury…I went down 5 times and got back up…#6 @ “53” put me out…4 herniation w 8 bulging disc n fractured vertebrae…3 knee surgeries…And NO I’m NOT a crier and NO I don’t look the part…I’m 5’10" 190#s and continue to work out and stay strong even at “60”…NO drugs and NO tears that can be seen…
I respect those old timers who played this game and I patterned my life in view of them and others like them…Toughness!!!…Get back up and go again…Today’s Players are a bunch of malcontent whinnying babies wanting all the $$$$ n glory but unwilling to live for it…Back in the day Alzado would have bitch slapped the lot of them…
This Is The Type Of NFLPA "BS" That Pisses Me Off!!!!...Meanwhile They Hold Onto Litigation...
“We want to go back to work, but we will not agree to a deal unless it’s the best deal for the players,” Mawae said.
“Our goal today is to see what is on the table and discuss outlying issues,” he added. “The players are not tied to a July 21 timeline. Our timeline is that which gives us the best deal for the players — today, tomorrow or whatever it might be.”
A frenzy of player activity, maybe unprecedented, also is in store. Teams should learn soon how quickly they can sign draft picks, negotiate with their own free agents, sign undrafted rookies, make trades, cut players and sign free agents.
This!!!...
Remaining issues are believed to include how to set aside three pending court cases: The players’ antitrust lawsuit against the NFL in federal court in Minnesota; the TV networks case, in which players accused owners of setting up $4 billion in "lockout insurance," money that the league would receive even if there were no games played in 2011; and a collusion case, in which players said owners conspired to restrict salaries last offseason.
It's no longer about...
getting on the field and just winning at all costs. It’s about bank accounts, Bentleys, and bling. Players would rather miss a tackle and cash their check than take the hit and risk injury. It is sad, but it is also what our world has become. We are a society based on finance, not achievement. This is not the case for all, of course, just a generalization, but I think it is the unfortunate truth that we are facing.
All sports are watered down. In Baseball, there are very few pitchers that go out and throw entire games, they get to 100 pitches and get pulled. This was not the case back in the day. There were pitchers that would come into a game in the 5th/6th inning, then start the next game of a double header and pitch the entire game! It was about the job, the game, not the bank account and how much $ can you stack over the longest period of time.
I just hope it doesn’t keep going in the current direction. If Brady or Manning get hurt this year, there might be a two hand touch installed for franchise QB’s.
"We can't stop here... This is bat country."
Jets' Scott says two-a-days keep players from going 'soft'...At Least One "OldSchool" Left...
“I think it’s wimping out; making football more soft,” Scott said. “No reason to try and make camp easy. I get concerned you’re making football players weaker because you don’t push them past that threshold.”
“You’re stealing reps from coaches,” Scott said.
“Two-a-days, it’s what football is all about,” he said. “It’s about endurance, pain, will, putting yourself through something when your body is telling you it doesn’t want to go. Your mind controlling your body. That’s what camp is all about. With one-a-days, guys might not be in as good of shape as they would have been. Camp tears you down, and then a smart coach starts pulling back in enough time that allows players’ bodies to build back up.”
NOT all "Jet"s are of this mold though…“S” Eric Smith said:
“Less hitting is always less toll on your body, but I don’t know if it would improve player safety or not,” Smith said. “A lot of these things are freak accidents that you can’t really stop.”
Fuck 'em.
I started watching football religiously because I needed my fix of dudes beating the living shit out of each other. I don’t give a shit about prissy little wankers like Brady whining about getting hit. Don’t want that? Don’t play football.
When I started playing, I wanted to play safety first because I just wanted to hit. Even now, I play two-way whenever I can. I’m 5’10" and 175 pounds (conversion) and pride myself on hitting blokes like I’m twice my size. In any contact sport I play.
Tough but clean, and sometimes dirty as well. That’s how football should be. Not a sport for overpaid fuckin’ pretty boys. I may as well just spend my spring/summers watching rugby league highlights and tapes and playing football, knowing that we still have the brutality in our game.
"In football, I root for the Oakland Raiders because they hire castoffs, outlaws, malcontents, and fuck -ups, they have lots of penalties, fights, and paybacks, and because Al Davis told the rest of the pig NFL owners to go get fucked. Someday, the Raiders will be strong again, and they will dip the ball in shit and shove it down the throats of the wholesome, white, heartland teams that pray together and don't deliver late hits." - George Carlin.

by 































