It would seem most posters on here prefer a defensive pick with our #5 pick. Ive heard a lot of folk citing that the top QB's are all a reach for that first pick. Say this is the way Reggie is thinking, and he goes D. Even if we snare a QB in F.A, Reggie may still want a lower round pick QB. He may go that way, even without an F.A.
The question is this, who do we go for? I've seen a lot of names banded about. Trade back in the 1st for Carr. Lower picks on Mettenburger, Murray; Garoppolo, Fales, McCarron, Boyd etc.
Who's your man, should this scenario play out, and why?