clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Rival Report 5/23: Report says NFL tried to influence government head trauma study

New, comments
Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports

The NFL continues to shoot themselves in the foot with unnecessary mistakes. This one is a doozy though, even by NFL standards. According to an Outside the Lines ESPN report, the NFL offered a $16 Million donation to a government run National Institute of Health (NIH) brain study, which they then took back after they decided they did not like the person chosen to head the study.

The absurdity of this is pretty clear, they wanted the good press of the donation but only if they had somebody they trusted doing the research. When the NIH announced that Neurodegenerative disease specialist Robert Stern was the person in charge of the study, the NFL decided that the NIH could not use their money for the research because of a perceived bias against them.

Robert Stern has been vocal about the effects of CTE and criticism of the NFL in the way they have handled this issue. The NFL takes that to mean he is biased in his studies against them, though there is absolutely no proof that his stance is based in bias as opposed to his professional opinion of the traumatic effects on the brain from football.

Here is the funny part though, the other doctor that was considered to lead the study actually works FOR the NFL. He is Dr. Richard Ellenbogen and is a co-chairman of the NFL's committee on brain injuries, and also their leading advocate opposing Dr. Robert Stern's findings.

That's right folks, the NFL literally revoked money to be used on a study because of a perceived bias after their own key doctor with a conveniently opposite opinion of the doctor was not chosen for the study. Pot meet kettle. The NFL wanted their guy in charge of a government study that directly financially affected their league, but it was bias against them when a different, unaffiliated to the NFL doctor was chosen.

When that obvious conflict of interest made the hiring of Dr. Ellenbogen rightfully be declined, the NFL decided to take their ball and go him instead of allow the NIH to proceed unobstructed. The clear ethical violations concerning attempting to influence an important government study are absurd, though entirely unsurprising considering the way the NFL has conducted themselves over the years regarding this topic.

The study will go on anyway, just without funds from the NFL and instead funded by taxpayer money that would have been spent on other important studies. The $16M the NFL had donated came from a $30M fund created by the NFL in 2012 that claimed to have "no strings attached" to it. They obviously forgot about that one string that did come with the money though, the string where only NFL backed doctors were to run the "unbiased" studies.

Congressional report finds NFL improperly intervened in brain research, cost taxpayers $16 million - ESPN
Congressional investigators have concluded that top NFL health officials waged an improper, behind-the-scenes campaign to influence a U.S. government research study on football and brain disease.

NFL officials attempted to influence NIH brain study - Sports Illustrated
NFL health officials reportedly attempted to influence a National Institutes of Health research study on football and brain disease.

ESPN: Congressional Investigators Find NFL Tried To Use Federal Agency As Propaganda Arm - Deadspin
Six months ago, Outside the Lines reported that the NFL pulled $16 million of funding from a National Institutes of Health study that was meant to further explore football’s relationship to CTE because it didn’t like the neurologist who’d been selected to lead the study.

Other stories from around the AFC West

Denver Broncos

Broncos reportedly reached out to free agent running back Arian Foster - Mile High Report
Foster isn't signing with the Broncos. (MAK: I think the Raiders should bring Foster in, if healthy he can contribute big and if not the Raiders are able to usurp his injury)

Bradley Roby looks to improve in his third season - Mile High Report
Third-year cornerback Bradley Roby might be overshadowed by teammates Aqib Talib and Chris Harris Jr., but that isn't changing his mindset in regard to becoming the best player he can be.

San Diego Chargers

San Diego Chargers Roster Review: How good is Brandon Mebane? - Bolts From The Blue
Kyle Posey examines another of Telesco's offseason acquisitions.

Mayor may not be burning down Chargers stadium | SanDiegoUnionTribune.com
Chargers fans groups calling for San Diego mayor’s ouster Page 1 of 2

Kansas City Chiefs

Kansas City Chiefs tight ends have one sure thing and then the questions begin - Arrowhead Pride
Let's start reviewing the Kansas City Chiefs by position. Up today, the tight ends...

Observations on the Chiefs’ nine draft picks, others from rookie camp | The Kansas City Star
Here are some observations at the conclusion of the Chiefs’ annual three-day rookie minicamp on Monday. I watched all three practices over the weekend, and took away some general thoughts.

Other stories from around the NFL

NFL - Players with most to prove for all 32 teams - free agency, draft picks, pivotal season, Jimmy Graham, Eddie Lacy - ESPN

Can Jimmy Graham rebound from his season-ending injury? Will Eddie Lacy return to his 2014 form? NFL Nation reporters select the player for each team facing a pivotal 2016 season.

NFL considering this major change to replay review | NJ.com

If passed, how we look at NFL replay and which calls should be challenged will be fundamentally changed.