clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Rival Report 8/23: NFL defends Giants K Josh Brown's 1 game suspension for domestic violence

New, comments
Andrew Weber-USA TODAY Sports

Remember when the NFL revamped their discipline policies for domestic violence which created a mandatory 6 game ban for a player's first offense? That just proved to not be so mandatory after all when New York Giants kicker Josh Brown received a one game suspension after police were called to his house twice in a 2 day span on domestic violence situations on May 22nd of 2015.

At the time his then-wife Molly Brown (now ex-wife) told police that Josh Brown had been physically violent with her 20 times going as far back as 2009 and that even included incidents when she was pregnant as well. The problem with the case came when Molly Brown stopped cooperating with any investigations into the matter. The charges were then dropped altogether 5 days later.

The NFL decided that enough happened during that time to warrant some sort of punishment but attempted to investigate the matter more fully. The problem was that Molly Brown wasn't willing to talk to them either about the incident and the police also were unable to provide more detailed information. After 10 months of investigation the NFL decided they didn't have enough evidence for their mandatory 6-game ban and made it a 1 game suspension for the opening game of the 2016 season instead.

"As a result of these factors, our investigators had insufficient information to corroborate prior allegations. In addition, no criminal charges were brought forward regarding the incident in question or prior allegations." the NFL wrote in a statement on Friday. "The N.F.L. therefore made a decision based on the evidentiary findings around this one incident as provided to us by the district attorney."

It's a tough situation to be in for the NFL, they could have tried to institute the 6-game mandatory ban off of police being called to Brown's house but it likely would have been another long contested battle had they tried to. With charges being dropped altogether and an uncooperative witness they didn't have enough evidence to test this in the court system.

The NFL's failure to use their domestic violence penalties here does create grey area in the mandatory ban they supposedly instituted. The police were still called to Brown's residence twice in two days for domestic violence situations even if Molly Brown stopped cooperating with police on the investigation.

So then are we to take it as the blanket ban is only for players convicted of domestic abuse? So basically, if NFL players do beat up a woman then they better make sure she stops talking so that they can avoid the real penalties that were supposed to be handed down. That sounds like grey area to me for sure, and it also sounds like a policy that is going to make victims of domestic abuse by NFL players more likely to be threatened or bought off into silence afterwards.

NFL statement: Josh Brown’s ex- wife, police wouldn’t cooperate with NFL investigation | ProFootballTalk
Read the full statement from the NFL here.

NFL defends 1-game suspension for Giants K Josh Brown - SBNation.com
Brown’s ex-wife told police the kicker was physically violent with her more than 20 times.

N.F.L. Says Stymied Investigation Led to One-Game Ban for Josh Brown - The New York Times
Brown was arrested in May 2015, but the charges were dropped and the league said Friday it "made a decision based on the evidentiary findings around this one incident."

NFL: Josh Brown only banned 1 game because ex-wife didn’t talk | New York Post
The NFL said it suspended Giants kicker Josh Brown one game — instead of the new "baseline’’ punishment of six games for first-time domestic abuse offenders — because of "insufficient information’’ stemming from Brown’s ex-wife’s refusal to cooperate with the league’s investigation.

Other stories from around the AFC West

Denver Broncos

Pete's Take: Broncos quarterback situation is clear as mud - Mile High Report
Week 2 of the preseason was a much tougher out for the Denver Broncos. For how badly the Broncos whipped up on the 49ers during scrimmage, when the lights were on and pads were donned, it was anything but a dominant performance by the Broncos.

Broncos vs 49ers: Preseason No Bull Review - Mile High Report
In the 2nd preseason game of the 2016 NFL season, we are gaining some clarity on all things Bronco: QB situation, RB competition, offensive line play, and defensive depth.

San Diego Chargers

BREAKING: D.J. Fluker injured in practice - Bolts From The Blue
This is not good news. Not good at all.

San Diego Chargers preparing without No. 3 draft pick Joey Bosa - San Diego Chargers Blog- ESPN
San Diego Chargers 2016 first-round pick Joey Bosa -- the No. 3 overall pick -- still isn't in camp because of a contract dispute.

Kansas City Chiefs

NFL roster cuts: A few of the Chiefs hardest decisions coming - Arrowhead Pride
The Kansas City Chiefs will trim their 90-man roster to 75 players by August 30 and they’ll go down to 53 players by September 3. This is a deep roster that will require plenty of tough decisions. ...

The Chiefs defense with and without Justin Houston - Arrowhead Pride
Every Chiefs fan is probably wringing their hands at the thought of starting the 2016 season without Justin Houston.

Other stories from around the NFL

DeMeco Ryans still waiting for right opportunity to return to NFL | AL.com

After 10 NFL seasons, former Alabama All-American DeMeco Ryans would like to play an 11th.

Travelers beware: The NFL and other leagues are taxing you

Taxing tourists to build new stadiums is more popular than ever. Check your hotel bill.