Blue chip players vs. above average starters

Just wondering what your thoughts are. With a roster like ours would you guys prefer one blue chip player or 3 possibly above average starters. In my most recent draft one of the blue chip players fell so I traded back with the vikings at 21. Then traded back again with the cowboys, turning our first round pick into 3 additional second round picks. Second round picks were

Pick 44: Richie Grant S

Pick 48: Liam Eichenberg OT

Pick 49: Alim Mcneil DT

Pick 54: Wyatt Davis OG

All players would be big time contributors this year or something is clearly wrong. I personally would rather take the round 2 picks cause it gives me the flexibility to gamble on injured guys like dylan moses and Andre cisco later in the draft